Win a copy of The Edible Ecosystem Solution this week in the Forest Garden forum!

David Baillie

pollinator
+ Follow
since Jan 07, 2016
David likes ...
kids dog books chicken earthworks cooking solar wood heat woodworking homestead
Builder, tinkered, gardener, charcoal gasification enthusiast.
North central Ontario
Apples and Likes
Apples
Total received
57
In last 30 days
1
Total given
9
Likes
Total received
375
Received in last 30 days
5
Total given
172
Given in last 30 days
1
Forums and Threads
Scavenger Hunt
expand Pollinator Scavenger Hunt
expand First Scavenger Hunt

Recent posts by David Baillie

Kate Downham wrote:*puts moderator hat on*

Just a reminder that politics can't be discussed outside the cider press. If you want to talk about the politics of smart meters, please start a new thread in the cider press.

*takes moderator hat off*

I wonder if a DC solar pump would be a good idea? If you have somewhere that you can gravity feed from, you could pump to a tank when the sun is shining, and then you wouldn't need an inverter or batteries for that system. Or if the pump is just for irrigation and you can't gravity-feed then maybe a solar pump would still do the job for that.

point well taken. I did not want to be pro or con via smart meters just curious. If it came across that way I apologize.
Cheers,  David
2 days ago

Angelika Maier wrote:Thanks for all the replies! THe great thing John Is that our driller who does the bore (which is probably the same thing you mention) that he uses grundfoss pumps too. I have to get into the technical details once we decide what to do in general.
It is NOT about saving money. I think it is very clear that hooking up the grid is the cheapest option. IF it's a smart meter (and I need to find that out) then we simply don't want to be part of it. It is a political decision not helping the smart grid along and if it's a smart meter we want to figure out how to get off that grid without breaking the bank. Maybe my first step should be to figure out whether this is a smart meter or not.


Angelika Maier wrote:Thanks for all the replies! THe great thing John Is that our driller who does the bore (which is probably the same thing you mention) that he uses grundfoss pumps too. I have to get into the technical details once we decide what to do in general.
It is NOT about saving money. I think it is very clear that hooking up the grid is the cheapest option. IF it's a smart meter (and I need to find that out) then we simply don't want to be part of it. It is a political decision not helping the smart grid along and if it's a smart meter we want to figure out how to get off that grid without breaking the bank. Maybe my first step should be to figure out whether this is a smart meter or not.


Angelika could you explain what you mean by smart grid and what the issues are with it? In Ontario the term has a lot of meanings most of them mixed. Right now all it means is the meter will feed its readings to the company so they can avoid sending a meter reader around. There is a lot of talk about a smarter grid that can monitor solar and adjust power in the lines and reduce production by the utility but most of that is speculative at this point. Perhaps even turning off heavy loads like ac during periods of high demand temporarily to cut how much peak production is required. That is a good thing as peak production is usually the oldest most poluting generation. If the meter signal is the issue then a simple metal plate on the inside of the house should effectively direct the signal outwards... Everything has a cost, while I believe in a solar distributed energy future there are environmental  costs and drawbacks to any system.
Cheers,  David
3 days ago

Angelika Maier wrote:We are having a warm climate garden and the main reason why we want electricity is that we aim for a bore. We will install water tanks also (10K litres plus some smaller ones) water is something I want double and triple secure.
The second reason is power tools.
There is electricity on the property BUT there is a meter installed which looks pretty much like a smart meter to me. We are both opposed to smart meters and would never put that thing close to a dwelling etc, but we also don't want to be enablers of a smart grid.There are as well concerns that they might light a fire, but I don't know whether or not this happens with Australian meters (we are very close to bush).
What do we have to consider for a solar setup? What would the cost be? Or maybe a generator would do the trick? Is it even a smart meter?


The newer digital meters are actually much safer then the older turning dial models. Is that one a smart meter? Hard to say if by smart meter you mean it communicates with the utility wirelessly then probably if it's less than 10 years old. Usually the concern is the wifi signal but my personal opinion is the transformer, and communications gear required for an off grid system will be putting out more electro magnetic radiation then the wifi equipment on the meter.
Not many people talk about that though... if the power is there I would say use it. You could always leave the meter far away and branch from it to the house. That is a not uncommon solution.
Cheers, David
4 days ago
I believe the theory is sound but the problem you will run into is the inefficiencies of each part leaving no surplus. As mentioned above stirlings can be very efficient as long as they operate at high pressure with highly conductive materials and high temperature differentials between hot and cold. The whispergen from a decade ago was a good attempt at a commercial unit it used a sealed free piston design similar to spacecraft stirlings. It had promise then the cost of solar dropped like a stone. You mentioned a 2 hp engine which with losses will produce at best 1.25hp or roughly 1 kW per hour of electricity at full temperature production. By unpressurized Stirling standards that engine would weight several hundred pounds and require continuous maintenance. For roughly 1000 dollars you can do the same with solar and have no moving parts or maintenance... Not to be discouraging but it might go some way into explaining why you dont see stirlings around much. I would try it with tegs myself. Their efficiency is not great but would be similar to a homebuilt stirling. All opinions of course but I did chase the stirling rabbit down the hole for a while.
Cheers,  NF
1 week ago

C Chasens wrote:Has anybody got experience with silicon dioxide batteries - Soneil is a brand - for off-grid solar? I would really appreciate hearing your experiences.
I expect to replace our FLA battery bank in Fall 2021, and am researching possibilities.
Lithium Iron Phosphate sound good, but I am concerned that, up here in northern Canada, we are too cold for the temperature range.


Lithium iron have trouble charging when it is cold but no trouble discharging when cold. Some companies are incorporating heaters into their assemblies but an insulated sealed box with a small heater works just as well. 5 degrees celcius is fine. It's a little inconvenient but considering there is no absorb stage losses it's worth it. There is no off gassing so no problem with the heater or keeping them in a warm area.
My next bank will most likely be lithium.
1 month ago

C. West wrote:Me and my girlfriend have been looking at pre fab and simple design houses and trailers and the one we are most impressed by cost and looks wise is avrame.

As far as we can tell (and I have had some correspondence with the company as well) you buy the plans and they contact a lumber mill near you to cut the pieces needed to build and send to your location. after that we use the plans given and build, if I remember correct it takes only a few weeks, and only needs two people

ill linkto their website s those more experienced than me can take a look.

My main concerns are whether I as an inexperienced builder (have to framing and roofing, as well as helped build some sheds) am biting off more than I can chew, and the other main concern is that its hard to find any reviews, positive or negative. All info and videos of the a-frames come from them.

what do you all think?

ps I plan on heating it with a rocket mass heater, any concerns there with its shape/floor?

Any input welcome.

did anything come of this? Most of ontario townships have square footage minimums that rule out tiny homes. Curious if it went forwards...
Cheers,  David
1 month ago

Douglas Alpenstock wrote:Well it seems I accidentally muddied the waters. Not what I was aiming to do, so that's my bad.

It may be that the hardware is much more tolerant of voltages bouncing around, including brownout as the battery voltage drops and the system crashes. I suspect it's not sustainable, but the only way to really know is to experiment.

I've always liked old laptops for this sort of stuff. An old battery pack provides a buffer for power oddities, even if it only has five minutes' run time left in it.


Hi Douglas I think it was touched on earlier. I use a step down dc to dc voltage transformer to run my ryobi tools directly which is within that 18 to 20 volt window. It was fairly cheap. That was a step down from 24 volts. They also offered  step up from 12 volts... not sure step down from 48 is available but definitely an option...
Cheers,  David
1 month ago

Jeremy Bromwell wrote:Hey all - I'm totally new here but have done some reading and think this would be a great spot to ask for recommendations on a discovery that happened at the land I recently purchased in southeast TN.

As my dirt guy was working on grading out the driveway through what has been hay fields for years he uncovered a nice bubbling spring in a ditch that ran across the field. Unlike some of the other water we've discovered on land very quickly, without going very deep, there were 5 or 6 spots visibly bubbling close to one another.

Knowing that the city is a mess and they don't know where the water line is and that the well option is expensive and the one outfit in town can't get me water for several months he proposed this spring as an option that would get me water really quickly.

His approach is to get a 6 ft tile (culvert) that he would dig down to towards the source of the emerging water. The local place will make a cap for the tile as well with a hole in it for a well pump. He'd then be surrounding the vertical pipe/basin with gravel rock to keep it in place and keep the other water from rains flowing around the system.

This all seems to make sense to me and once he starts digging I can more accurately measure flow and get some water to have it tested to see if it's suitable for drinking as is or what kind of filtration/treatment would be needed.

My question for those with way more experience than me is - does this sound like a good approach? What should I be looking out for as we move forward? The site where I'll be building the home is a couple hundred feet away and about 50' higher than the top of this tank so I'm thinking I'll want some other elevated tank near the home site to actually create the right pressure inside but does that depend on the flow at the holding tank and type pump I get there?

I have talked to the gentleman that has been cutting hay on and next to this land for decades to ask him if that little section of the ditch ever went dry and he has said not that he knows of, which jives with the vegetation.

I'll keep digging through the other posts but also thought I would ask you guys (and gals) for advice about the situation that has recently become pressing! Thanks so much!

it sounds like a great option Jeremy. At 200 ft away and 50ft drop You would want a submersible pump min of 1/2 hp preferably 3/4 if you have a stable source of power. Those pumps could easily do the job directly to the house. I would want to have it tested though and maybe install a UV system at the house in case of seasonal contamination...
Cheers,  David
1 month ago

It depends how much water will you be drawing using the hand pump. A human in good shape can realistically only generate 150 to 200 watts of power per hour so roughly 1/4 hp. A 1/2 hp pump can draw roughly 6 to 10gpm depending on depth so assume you might get half that... if that is ok then I would install a hand pump. Next comes what depth the static pressure is since even if they hit water at 200ft might come up to 30 ft from the surface. Next I would consider the cost of the hand pump setup. If it is more expensive then a generator to run the electric pump you will be installing eventually I would just buy a generator and store it in a shed to run the pump whenever I was there and have a power source to boot...
That is how I would proceed..
Cheers,  David
1 month ago

Nicole From Maui wrote:Hi there, we've been recommended Blue Ion batteries for our solar setup. Anyone using them? If so, any feedback would be great.
Thanks!

they are in your neck of the woods so local is good. They use a lithium iron cel similar to the ones used in most of the better lithium systems. You are buying a pretty high end battery with cool case, mounting system, power rails etc. For a comparison simpliphi is a less high end product with near identical cels but less packaging... price per watt is a fair bit lower...
https://www.altestore.com/store/deep-cycle-batteries/lithium-batteries/simpliphi-power-smart-tech-lithium-batteries-p40602/#SIMPHI3_8-48V

Cheers,  David
1 month ago