I received two purple mooseages from different people, one warning me that using grass clippings will result in disaster (per a
permie course) and another asking me why grass clippings work for me because she had been warned not to use them. So rather than keep my
answer private, I've decided to answer publicly.
Perhaps clippings work for a few reasons.
1- The clippings are rather coarse, since the grasses are pasture grass rather than fine leafed front yard lawns. In the past I have used lawn clippings, but I applied them thinly so to avoid that clumpy, gooey problem. Years ago I had success using lawn clippings. I would use them today if that was what I had available.
2- Apply thinly and fluffy so that they can dry. They will mat somewhat with time, but not to that gooey black muck, which is to be avoided.
3- Gradually built up the depth of the mulch for crops needing good light protection, such as potatoes and leeks. I've built up mulch to 7-9 inches for such crops.
4- Apply to plants that are growing large enough not to get covered with the mulch. I don't apply clippings to small stuff like baby beets that will get smothered when a breeze blows the clippings over them. I wait until plants are larger.
I was warned that clippings would rob my soil of nitrogen. I haven't found that to be the case with clippings laying atop the soil as a mulch. My soil hosts a decent population of soil micro organisms, which perhaps prevents that problem. A part of keeping the soil "alive" is keeping it moist and the direct sunlight off, both of which can be accomplished via the clippings mulch.
I was warned that tilling in the old mulch would bind up soil nitrogen. But again, my soil is host to various soil micro organisms and worms. And I don't till in fresh clippings. I have not see nitrogen depravation in my crops. Plus I don't till in excessive amounts of mulch, like that found on my potatoes and leeks. The excess mulch is moved to other crops before tilling.
I was warned that grass clippings mulch would prevent rain from reaching the soil. Again, I have not seen that. I apply mulch fairly thin, keeping it about 2 inches thick in most cases. Importantly I apply mulch to already moist soil, NOT dry soil. I find that my mulch helps keep the soil moist but reducing evaporation due to sun and wind. Yes, a light rain may not penetrate the mulch, but it still will help keep the soil from drying out. Heavier rains definitely get through my grass mulch.
I hope this answers the questions raised.