Author Message
Edward Norton
Post     Subject: Bullshit by Vandana Shiva

People wear different hats. She studied physics at university and her qualification enabled her to work Bhabha Atomic Research Centre - that makes her a physicist. Physics and Philosophy is a dream combination, the two  fundamental subjects. I most definitely wouldn't want to get into an argument with someone having studied both to the level she has.
David Wieland
Post     Subject: Bullshit by Vandana Shiva

Suzy Bean wrote:About this Movie
Vandana Shiva In this documentary, we follow environmental activist and nuclear physicist Vandana Shiva

How can Shiva claim to be a "nuclear physicist"? She's definitely an activist, but here's her post-secondary education as stated in the Wikipedia entry on her:

Shiva studied physics at Panjab University in Chandigarh, graduating as a Bachelor of Science in 1972.[11] After a brief stint at the Bhabha Atomic Research Centre, she moved to Canada to pursue a master's degree in the philosophy of science at the University of Guelph in 1977 where she wrote a thesis entitled "Changes in the concept of periodicity of light".[11][12] In 1978, she completed and received her PhD in philosophy at the University of Western Ontario,[13] focusing on philosophy of physics. Her dissertation was titled "Hidden variables and locality in quantum theory" in which she discussed the mathematical and philosophical implications of hidden variable theories that fall outside of the purview of Bell's theorem.

The "philosophical implications of hidden variables"? She can accurately be called a philosopher -- but not a physicist.
Dale Hodgins
Post     Subject: Bullshit by Vandana Shiva

Several years ago a company patented a fungicide based on the neem tree, which Indians have used for thousands of years. The Indian government sued and won. They claim that it was part of traditional Indian knowledge and they called a ton of people in support of that. I'm pretty sure I heard her name mentioned concerning this.

Now, patent offices are expected to make sure that naturally occurring substances aren't patented. Of course that doesn't prevent all forms of skullduggery. It was a big win for the organic movement in India and around the world.
Suzy Bean
Post     Subject: Bullshit Award given to Vandana Shiva

About this Movie

This Week, Thursday September 22
Bullshit          (USA/India: 2005, 73 min.)
Thursday, September 22, 2011, 7:00pm, U.C. Theater
With Vandana Shiva
Opponents gave her the Bullshit Award
Time Magazine hailed her as one of the great heroes of our time.

Vandana ShivaIn this documentary, we follow environmental activist and nuclear physicist Vandana Shiva for a period of two years, a whirlwind tour from her organic farm at the foot of the Himalayas to the summit of the World Trade Organization in Mexico to a protest outside the European Patents Office in Munich. Here, in these institutions of power, Shiva does battle with the proponents of globalization, multi-national corporations like Monsanto, an American bio-tech company manufacturing genetically modified foods (whom Shiva holds responsible for a rash of farmers’ suicides) and Coca-Cola, accused of depleting and contaminating groundwater in India.

A portrait of a tireless and fearless activist (Shiva is a recipient of the Right Livelihood Award and the United Nations’ Earth Day International Award), Bullshit also gives voice to the small farmers affected by these policies, as well as to some of her staunchest opponents, including executives from Monsanto and Coca-Cola, and especially Barun Mitra, a neo-liberal lobbyist who gave Shiva the “Bullshit Award” for espousing lies about the negative effects of globalization (upon receiving the award, Shiva mockingly retorted that “cow dung is the most beautiful of materials”).

An insightful, eye-opening, and exhilarating film, Bullshit elucidates some of the most pressing social and technological questions of the 21st century – can genetically modified foods alleviate world hunger? is it legal for corporations to patent natural crops? can indigenous knowledge inform modern genetic engineering? – as it takes you to the frontlines of the war over globalization.

The Movie

YouTube Channels

Related Websites
Vandana Shiva
The Seeds of Vandana Shiva
Humans and Nature